There is very little debate that Aaron Rodgers is Ted Thompson’s best draft pick during his 10 years as general manager of the Green Bay Packers. If Thompson would have passed on Rodgers because the Packers didn’t need a quarterback, the recent history of the Packers would have been quite different.
But who is Thompson’s second-best draft choice? Luckily, if you’re a Packers fan, there have been plenty of prime candidates. Here are the top 5, in my not so humble opinion:
Clay Matthews, 2009
Not only has Matthews been one of the best defensive players in the NFL, Thompson uncharacteristically traded back into the first round to grab him. The rare Thompson trade-up gives Matthews a couple extra points in the race for second best Thompson draft pick of all time.
Josh Sitton, 2008
It’s not often you find a player who might be the best in the league at his position group in the fourth round, but that’s what Thompson did with Sitton. Durable, dependable, and really freaking good — Sitton ranks right up there with the best of Thompson’s picks.
Mike Daniels, 2012
The 2012 draft is one that Thompson would probably like to forget. Nick Perry, Jerron McMillian, Terrell Manning and B.J. Coleman…bleh. But Thompson struck gold once again in the fourth round with Daniels. Imagine how weak the Packers defensive line would have been without Daniels last season?
Nick Collins, 2005
Packers fans didn’t realize how good they had it with Collins at safety until Collins’ career was suddenly ended in 2011. Until the arrival of Ha Ha Clinton-Dix last season, safety had been a black hole in Collins’ absence.
Greg Jennings, 2006
Jennings over Randall Cobb? Yes, Jennings over Cobb, at least for now. With the Packers, Jennings put up big numbers and had several memorable moments, including a ridiculous catch from a ridiculous throw from Rodgers in Super Bowl XLV. Nothing wrong with being mad at Jennings for the way he left Green Bay, but don’t discount his impact on getting the Packers to where they are today.
So, who would I pick as Thompson’s second-best draft choice ever? I say it’s Matthews. It’d be nice if Thompson could draft Matthews a new hamstring, but when you look at talent, impact, energy, hustle and the complete package, Matthews delivers.
What say you?——————
Adam Czech is a a freelance sports reporter living in the Twin Cities and a proud supporter of American corn farmers. When not working, Adam is usually writing about, thinking about or worrying about the Packers. Follow Adam on Twitter. Twitter .
13 thoughts on “Ted Thompon’s 2nd best draft pick for the Green Bay Packers is ____________”
I would go with Matthews as TT’s second best draft pick. He has been an impact player for the Packers and opposing offensive coordinators need to account for him on every play. When he is injured there is a noticeable difference in the Packers defense. Last year CM3’s ability to move to ILB and play effectively saved the Packers run defense and proved how versatile and important Matthews is for the Packers. While I agree that Sitton has been an exceptional pick by TT, Matthews gets my vote for TT’s second best draft pick. Thanks, Since ’61
You could argue that it would have been Nick Collins had he not gotten hurt. He was the Packers best defender right next to Charles Woodson and Clay Matthews and I think he would have been the league’s next great safety.
Jordy Nelson ???
Damn! Totally forgot about Jordy Nelson.
I’d say CM3. If I were grading on a curve, i.e. taking into consideration round, then I would suggest Sitton.
I’d also have to say Matthews. He’ll be in the hall of fame more than likely when he wraps up his 20 year career since longevity is in their bloodline. The next one I will go with Eddie “the hammer” Lacy.
This is a fun discussion to have. Our GM is a draft savant!
Damn right Bearmeat!!
Does that mean he’s gay?
Sherrod, Newhouse, Jones, Mandarich(are you awake), etc…
My vote is for Sitton. Those big guys up front don’t get enough credit. Josh is held in high respect by all of the other offensive linemen. He leads both by word and example.
Nick “The Pick” Collins!!! In my opinion 2nd best over matthews closer 3rd. if Collins kept up his career he could have been a hall of famer… sad to see him go out the way he did its possible we could have another super bowl with him…
Comments are closed.