2013 Packers Position Group Analysis: Kickers & Specialists

ALLGBP.com All Green Bay Packers All the Time

Overview: To kick off the next series of evaluations on AllGreenBayPackers.com, the ALLGBP staff are going to be analyzing each position group starting off with the specialists.  Overall, the specialists did a pretty good job keeping their names off the papers and blogs, outside of about 6 weeks of utter CROSBPOCALYPSE.

Where We Are Now

Here are the current suspects;

  • LS Brett Goode (Undrafted, 2008)
  • P Tim Masthay aka Ginger Wolverine (Undrafted, 2010)
  • K Mason Crosby (6th round, 2007)

Listen to expanded coverage of this topic using the player below or download the podcast from the Packers Talk Radio Network on Itunes.

Listen to internet radio with Packers Talk Radio Network on Blog Talk Radio

So that’s where we are.  Not much to report here; specialists are often drafted in the later rounds or not at all, and the Packers are no different, only using a 6th round pick on Crosby and picking up both Goode and Masthay off the free agent street.

  • Goode: Goode again finished the season without a bad snap and even recorded a tackle in week 9 against the Cardinals, a pretty hard feat considering Goode has the least idea of what’s going on on the field since his head is between his legs at the beginning of the play.  Goode was also not responsible for any blocked or batted kicks which overall for a long snapper basically is a job well done
  • Masthay: Tim Masthay ranked in the middle of the pack in terms of punting efficiency on ProFootballFocus, which can mostly be attributed to his lack of power, but Masthay makes up for that and more with his accuracy and hangtime.  Masthay uses his “aussie” style drop kick as well as his good directional skills to pin opponents back and usually never outkicks his coverage.  Outside of one misguided pass play that I wouldn’t really put as Masthay’s fault, Masthay had a consistent yet basically unremarkable season, but for a special teams unit that has been desperate for just an average punter after Jon Ryan’s departure, Masthay was a godsend.
  • Crosby: What can we say about Crosby that hasn’t already been said?  He had a terrible segment (Weeks 8 to 16) sandwiched between two overall good segments (Week 1 to 7 and through the playoffs).  At it’s lowest you had to question how much Crosby’s play was effecting McCarthy’s strategic thinking; while McCarthy may not have lost complete faith in his kicker, trying out risky 4th down trick plays started to suddenly seem like a better bet.  Also, it seems like Crosby and fellow kicker David Akers proved really how important the kicking game is to a team’s success with the Packers making it to the Divisional Round while the 49ers got to the Superbowl.  Overall, I think many fans only remember the bad bit in the middle but overall Crosby still managed to come out of the season with a 14.7 overall grade in 2012, while certainly not a good grade by any means, not the absolute dumpster fire fans make his season out to be.

Where We Want To Be

Overall the specialists played well; both Masthay and Goode played up to standard and I would be very surprised to see the Packers even waste a roster spot on another punter or long snapper, even if only to provide Masthay and Goode some competition during the offseason and OTAs.  On the other hand, based on both Ted Thompson’s and Mike McCarthy’s public claims of faith to Crosby I wouldn’t be surprised to see either a veteran free agent or undrafted rookie get onto the 80 man roster at the beginning of the offseason to try to push Crosby a little during training camp.  Would they go as far as spending a late draft pick on another kicker?  My intuition says no, Crosby was recently resigned to a fairly hefty contract so cutting him is unlikely.

How We Get There

The specialist are in place and outside of maybe some cheap competition for Crosby I don’t see much happening in the offseason.  Packers and fans alike are just hoping that Crosby’s season was just a aberration and he will regress to the mean and end up being a ~80% kicker with a strong leg.


Thomas Hobbes is a staff writer for Jersey Al’s AllGreenBayPackers.com.


6 thoughts on “2013 Packers Position Group Analysis: Kickers & Specialists

  1. Goode is good. Had to say that.

    Masthay is very effective at placement.

    Hope Mason has his head clear and gets ready for the competition from the “Italian Stalion.”

  2. As far as I can remember, Goode hasn’t had a bad snap since he has been with the Packers.

    Crosby might be able to learn something from #61, though the pressure of making a crucial kick is probably rather more than a long-snapper feels.

    1. That’s a bit of a stretch, long snapping and kicking are completely different things. I’ll also say that while kicking is influenced by the snap, snapping isn’t really affected by the kick, so Crosby does have to deal with more variables than Goode does.

  3. Chances are Crosby retains his job, he cannot kick under pressure but pressure is not a part of camp and exhibition games. In McCarthy’s only losing season (6-10 in 2008)3 of the losses can be attributed to his failure to kick under pressure, he has one game winner and that was in his rookie year. With the record setting offense putting the team ahead early his chances to kick under pressure recently have been few but when they have appeared he has “choked”, the kick to tie the Colt’s game missed so bad it looked like it was blocked but it was not blocked. Fortunately we have a solid punter with an up side and an outstanding long snapper. Thompson will need a short list on kickers, McCarthy’s emphasis is ACCOUNTABILITY, don’t look for him exclude Crosby two years in a row.

    1. This is somewhat like the argument that Aaron Rodgers isn’t a clutch QB, which statistically is true, but I’d rather have Rodgers than any other QB right now. But really, Rodgers doesn’t have all that many chances to be clutch because the Packers strategy is to score as many points as possible early and then run out the clock (which is a fine strategy in my opinion). Crosby has the same problem, he doesn’t have many game winning/tying kicks for the same reason. Has he missed on chances? Yes, but the Packers as a whole aren’t good at the come from behind win, I don’t know why, but that’s the identity of the whole team.

Comments are closed.