Aaron Rodgers and Illegal Hits: When Will the NFL Walk the Talk?

ALLGBP.com All Green Bay Packers All the Time

When I read that Chicago Bears defensive end Julius Peppers was fined $10,000 by the NFL today for a helmet-to-helmet hit on Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers in Sunday’s NFC Championship, one thought and one thought only went through my head:


For a player who recently signed a huge free agent contract that could total $91.5 million, $10,000 is like pennies to you and me. During the regular season, the NFL apparently made it crystal clear to teams and players that hits that involve the leading of the helmet would not be tolerated and would be met with stiff fines and possible suspensions.

If $10,000 is a stiff fine to multi-millionaires, then I’m the King of England.

Look at Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker James Harrison (who the Packers will face in Super Bowl XLV). He has been fined for times for illegal hits and the fines total $125,000 for an average of roughly $31,000 per offense. Again, pocket change to the millionaire players of the NFL.

But let’s get back to Peppers, and more importantly for Packer fans, Rodgers.

This is not the first time Peppers has rung Rodgers’ “bell.” In a regular season game at Lambeau Field in 2008, Peppers was flagged for a bruising hit on Rodgers out of bounds when he played for the Carolina Panthers. That hit can be seen here: Julius Peppers Nails Aaron Rodgers

If the NFL really is taking multiple offenses seriously, why aren’t they looking at past seasons so they can definitively establish a pattern of illegal hits from a player? As a lot of fans are so fond of saying when criticizing coaches, it’s not one game—it’s the “body of work.”

Worse yet, this fine once again raises a question that Packer fans have been asking over the past year and maybe more:

“Why is the league so interested in protecting 31 other quarterbacks but not Aaron Rodgers?”

Is some of this fan protectionism of “their” guy? Possibly. Have other quarterbacks taken shots like Rodgers has and not had a flag thrown? No question.

Still, it seems like Rodgers takes more illegal hits that don’t get called than any other quarterback in the league. The question everyone is asking is: why?

First off, I’m not here to start some kind of grand conspiracy theory. I don’t think the league office has it out for Rodgers or that they’re picking on him in any way shape or form.

The main reason I believe for the lack of calls has been Rodgers’ style of play. As a quarterback who moves out of the pocket quite well and is able to throw on the run, he is opening himself up to more brutal hits by linebackers and corners rather than taking hits by slower defensive linemen had he stayed in the pocket. Look at some the hits Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Mike Vick took during the season.

This doesn’t mean Rodgers should change his style of play. No way, Jose. Rodgers is one of the most athletic quarterbacks in the game and the Packers should continue to utilize all his abilities. I personally love Rodgers’ game and he should keep doing what he’s doing. He isn’t the issue here.

What IS the issue is a league that seems to be at a crossroads when it comes to player safety. If they go one way, they’re being far too lenient on the player. They go the other way, and they’re accused of “wussifying” the game. It’s a tough spot for the NFL to be in, especially with all the new data being brought about players’ long term health after they retire from football.

What the league CAN and SHOULD do, however, is start suspending repeat offenders and stripping them of game checks for intentional hits. Football is a violent game and it’s impossible to nearly get rid of the violent collisions considering the size and speed of NFL players today.

Would a “safety official” up in the replay booth be the answer? I don’t know. I don’t know what the answer would be.

All I’m saying is the league needs to walk the walk and talk the talk. If they say they are going to say they will be imposing “stiff “ fines on players for illegal hits, then do it. Be consistent. Do what you say you are going to do.

Is that so hard to ask?


Kris Burke is a sports writer covering the Green Bay Packers for AllGreenBayPackers.com and WTMJ in Milwaukee. He is a member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA) and his work has been linked to by sites such as National Football Post and CBSSports.com.


12 thoughts on “Aaron Rodgers and Illegal Hits: When Will the NFL Walk the Talk?

  1. Fines are toothless. Time is far more precious. If only there were some system to model this on, where players get warnings and/or immediate in-game suspensions for foul play….

  2. There have been many jokes around here in Pittsburgh about Harrison getting fined for other people’s penalties. Like when Big Ben got his nose broken, everyone was saying that Harrison would get charged for it.

    It’s really become a joke, but now that you’ve pointed out Peppers’ measely fine, I am infuriated.

    Harrison got fined $25k for hitting Ryan Fitzpatrick in the CHEST with his helmet.

    That shot by Peppers was completely uncalled for, and a $10k fine is not enough. The NFL needs to stop being so biased in doling out the fines. If Rodgers wasn’t wearing that new helmet, he probably would be dealing with a concussion. That shot was downright vicious, and he had plenty of time to line it up.

    Peppers (and whoever is in charge of these fines) can now join Urlacher on my ****-list.

  3. So I watched the video one more time, and I still stand behind my convictions. I also noticed Briggs give Rodgers a nice smack to the other side of his face at the same time Peppers hit him. The Briggs hit can be forgiven, as he was trying to swat the ball. But that Peppers hit makes my blood boil…

  4. “Still, it seems like Rodgers takes more illegal hits that don’t get called than any other quarterback in the league”

    I agree with the general point of the article, but Vick and Roethlisberger take a hell of a lot more. Vick in particular gets hit out of bounds all the time and it’s never flagged.

    1. I don’t watch those teams enough to know whether they get hit more or lass than Rodgers, but certainly agree they take their share of hits too.

  5. I wonder if fining players a percentage of their game check (and somehow factoring in their signing bonus) would help any.

    Let’s put the figure at 10 percent. If Frank Zombo drills a QB in the head, he’d get fined 10 percent of his game-check, which is based on a league minimum salary. If Peppers drills somebody in the head, he’d get fined 10 percent of his game check, which is a WHOLE lot more than Zombo’s.

    Just a thought…..

  6. Why is protecting Aaron Rodgers more important than Mike Vick? Double standards exist even in sports. Mike didn’t even get a flag thrown in his behalf on Sunday.

Comments are closed.