Week 2 Packers Stock Report: Wells and Cobb Rising, Shields Falling

ALLGBP.com All Green Bay Packers All the Time
Packers C Scott Wells enters the rising category in the Packers stock report.

Before we get into the Packers week two stock report, lets look at the overall stock of the NFL after the first week of games. Even though Thursday night’s opener between the Packers and Saints easily won the night, ratings were down about three percent compared to last year’s Saints/Vikings opener.

After years of TV ratings (and profits) continuing to go up, has the NFL reached its peak? What role did the lockout play in the reduced rating? Did having two small-market teams in the opener bring the number down?

The answer to all those questions is probably “it’s too early to tell.” However, I don’t notice the same level of buzz around the NFL that I’ve noticed over the last couple of years. There were some people at work on Thursday that weren’t even aware the season was starting that night. A lot of my friends that are casual football fans also haven’t brought up the NFL much over the last month.

The NFL will remain the top dog in American sports for a long time, but you have to think it will reach a peak in popularity sometime. Maybe that time is now, but I doubt it. With the NFL set to get new TV contracts shortly, I’m sure we’ll hear about record ratings and attendance as the year goes on.

Regardless of which way NFL stock is headed, the Packers have probably never been as popular as they are now. They’re a team at the top that appears to be rising even higher after beating the Saints.

There were some tough omissions from the rising category this week. Honorable mention goes to B.J. Raji, Ryan Pickett and Jarius Wynn on the defensive line and Morgan Burnett in the secondary.

Rising

Aaron Rodgers
I told myself I wasn’t going to include Rodgers in the rising category every week, but how can you leave him off after what he did against the Saints? He had no business making some of those throws, but he made them anyway and completed most of them. After the game, he even mocked people who questioned the fact that he did not organize player workouts during the lockout. Just a brilliant night for QB1.

Scott Wells
The Packers center was bulldozing Saints defensive linemen all night. I thought Cris Collinsworth was going to leave the broadcast booth and give Wells a kiss at one point in the game. Watching Wells make his initial block at the line of scrimage then work his way to the second level was a thing of beauty.

Randall Cobb
I went to fix myself a snack during a Saints kickoff because I assumed it would be just another touchback. Next thing I know my wife is going crazy and Cobb is taking the kick back for a TD. The Packers actually returned a kick for a TD! If he stays healthy, Cobb could be a Percy Harvin type of player. Buy now before other investors catch on.

Steady

Chad Clifton
It didn’t take long for Clifton to get himself out of the falling category. Rodgers had time to throw most of the night, and the veteran left tackle deserves a lot of the credit. Now is the time to buy on Clifton. If he stays hot, it won’t be long before his price is too high fore most investors.

Nick Collins
A forced fumble early, a couple of big hits, consistent play as the Packers “center fielder” at free safety; Collins has been solid for a while now. He’s one of those investments that stays at the same price, then occasionally yields a big gain.

John Kuhn
It didn’t take long for the first “Kuuuuuuuhn” chants of 2011 to reverberate throughout Lambeau Field. Investors can’t as much more from Kuhn, the guy delivers first downs and touchdowns when he carries the ball and provides some extra security for Rodgers.

Falling

Sam Shields
Uh-oh. Might teams have finally figured out to stay away from Tramon Williams and pick on Shields instead? It wasn’t pretty for Shields on Thursday. Investors will have to determine if Shields is a stock they need to dump, or if he’s just a young player going through growing pains.

Charles Woodson
Woodson played well enough on Thursday, but Charles, buddy, you can’t uppercut other players when the refs are looking. It’s probably not a good idea to uppercut people in the first place, but if you insist on uppercutting someone, make sure it’s not at the end of a scrum when every single ref on the field is running toward the pile to try and break it up. If he’s not suspended, I expect Woodson’s time in the falling category to be short, but throwing a punch is such a dumb move that he deserves a one-week sentence as a falling stock.

AJ Hawk
Like Woodson, Hawk played well enough Thursday, but he angered investors by missing a tackle on Pierre Thomas, which forced Tramon Williams to make the tackle. Williams hurt his shoulder when Collins crashed into him on the play. Hawk also had a questionable pass interference called against him as time ran out, but investors refused to give him the benefit of the doubt after the missed tackle before Williams’ injury.

The Watch List

The following players and coaches could end up in next week’s stock report:

Ryan Grant/James Starks
Starks shined brighter on Thursday, but I thought Grant looked fine when he got his carries. Starks is close to appearing in the rising category and I wouldn’t count Grant out just yet, either.

Shawn Slocum
Defending kick and punt returns was an adventure on Thursday. Didn’t Slocum fix this at the end of last season? Darren Sproles is tough for anyone to stop, so I left Slocum off the falling list this week, but investors are souring on him.

Jordy Nelson
Nelson is making a strong bid to appear in the steady category. I also like how he seems to gain a couple extra yards after each catch by running through the tackler.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

——————

Adam Czech is a freelance reporter and a Packers fan living in the Twin Cities. Follow Adam on Twitter. Read more of Adam's writing on the Packers here.

——————

  • PackersRS

    I think replacing Clifton in the steady category should be Bulaga. He played better than Clifton according to PFF, and after the struggles of last year, looks like a very solid RT. And he’s 22.

    • Ron LC

      Me too RS. This is not to detract from Clifton’s effort. He played steady and Clifton like. Bulaga was controllling his man.

      • Bubbaloo

        I agree with both of you on Bulaga, but he does play next to Sitton! All he needs to mind is his own business, and he’s doing great at it. As for the rest of this post, too early (1st game) to gripe, I thought Hawk played a hell of a game and GOT ROBBED on the PI call. There were so many missed tackles (by both teams) I won’t even consider blaming him for Tramon’s injury, that’s football.

    • Adam Czech

      I need to see a little more from Bulaga before he makes the report.

  • Chazman

    Is there a “we lost his stock portfolio” category? If so then James Jones is your man.

    • Adam Czech

      Jones is on the verge of being removed from the market by the SEC, but I wouldn’t count him out quite yet.

      • Steve Cheez

        Maybe Jones is a Ponzi scheme?

  • Chad Lundberg

    Why is Slocum still working in Green Bay?

  • Jer

    Heh. I’m glad I wasn’t the only one who missed the Cobb kick return. I returned from the bathroom to see the last 10 yards. They must have cut that commercial break short. :)

  • Elle

    I’d probably put Shields in the “watch” category. One bad week can happen to anyone. Williams got beat a few times too.

    • Adam Czech

      I try to avoid judging players on one bad week, but Shields also was a bit shaky in the Super Bowl and preseason.

  • Ron LC

    I think a prime cadidate for falling value was the guy who cut the tackling dummies from Capers budget. That was the poorest display of tackling technique since I played for Fort Richardson in an Army league.

  • Mojo

    How can Nelsons & Bulaga’s stock not be rising? I guess you’re only including three in each category.

    Shields scares me with both his coverage and incredibly poor tackling.

    Hawk was late to the ball and a sieve when he did get there. Sell all you can of this stock.

    The 400 plus yards the Pack gave up to Brees is what happens when a great QB is not pressured.

    • Adam Czech

      I am poor and don’t have much money to invest, so I try to limit it to no more than three per category. Nelson and Bulaga are making a lot of noise, however.

  • Thomas Hobbes

    To the Packers-Saints credit, the game was apparently the second highest rated prime time game since 1999, so by default that would have to make the saints-vikings game the highest. So there was a dip but I’m not sure it means anything just yet.

    • Adam Czech

      Agreed. For some reason I’m fascinated by the NFL’s popularity despite what it does to push its fan base away.

      • homerunsimpson

        because the nfl makes its money on the casual fan, not the hardcore faithful fans like us. were simply outnumbered

  • aaronqb

    If you’re selling Shields, I’m buying. He will be a star in the NFL. The lockout hurt his stock … buy low, sell high

  • Shavager

    Don’t bail on Shields yet, one game does not make a season or Packers are in trouble. If Brees can make 400+ yards without much pressure, think what Vick, Brady, Big Ben would do. They may even make Cutler look like a Manning. Hawks, Bishop, the D-line all whiffed on arm tackles. I can hear Vince now: “Grab, grab, grab, everybody’s grabbing” this defense needs tackle practice–hire Refrigerator Perry, put him in pads and force one on one tackling drills till they learn to tackle. It won’t take but one drill to fix this. Jordy looked great–Rodgers missed a sure TD to him with overthrow-stock slipped a half point, receivers looked great especially Cobb. Time to trade Jones? Give him till a crucial drop that costs game, then sell-his stock will have peaked.

    • Adam Czech

      Not bailing on Shields. Just saying his stock is down at the moment. It happens to a lot of players.